Rotterdam or Anywhere (1): Coaching Youth Hockey

Recently I was fortunate to have been given the opportunity to visit HC Rotterdam to learn about the coaching and operations of the hockey club.  It was definitely one of the most useful and enjoyable coach learning experiences that I have encountered and I came away with lots of new knowledge, and reflections on existing knowledge.  A few people have asked me about the visit and some of the learning from this, so I thought I'd share it via this post.  This post will be the first of two covering the visit, this one focusing on Youth Hockey at HC Rotterdam while the second will focus on other elements of the club visit (there was just too much Youth stuff to talk about to fit anything else into this post).  I've also added a few links to other related information that may be of use to coaches of children.  


HC Rotterdam Context
There was lots to be impressed by during the 5 days that the group spent at HC Rotterdam.  However, when reflecting upon what might be transferable to the local hockey setting it is important to consider:
  • The Scale of the Club (Approximately 2,500 playing members, including 1,400 Youth playing members; and 2,000 non-playing members).
  • The absence of Extra-Curricular School Hockey within the Netherlands, meaning that the club is the main point of contact for hockey for young players.
  • 11v11 Hockey begins at Under 12 within the Dutch system, with younger age-groups playing 3v3 and 6v6.
  • HC Rotterdam's facilities include seven artificial pitches (3 water-based & 4 sand-based).
The situation that HC Rotterdam is in provides many advantages in relation to massive participation numbers to feed the clubs senior teams, club income, available pitch space and joined-up approaches to player development.  However, it also presents challenges in relation to coordinating the huge operation of the club, selecting and managing almost unimaginable numbers of players, and maintaining the quality of the clubs provision. Impressively HC Rotterdam seem to be making the most of the advantages and challenges alike.


Youth Development
At Lisnagarvey HC my current focus is on supporting the coaches within the clubs Youth and Mini Hockey sections, so getting an understanding of the Youth provision at HC Rotterdam was my number one priority for the visit.  We were fortunate to have access to the clubs Youth Technical Director Kees Wortmann who was able to provide us with an in-depth insight into Youth provision to go alongside our observations of Youth training sessions and matches at various age-groups. Some of the notable factors were:

Children's Groups Aged 5-11: 
  • Maximum number of players in each group of 8.  Normally accompanied by 1 or 2 coaches, creating a coach:participant ratio of between 1:8 and 1:4.  Generally there were approximately 6 groups per pitch, leaving plenty of pitch space for each group.  
  • Many of the coaches operating with these groups were teenagers who facilitated mostly fun games for the kids to play, with the kids rotating around a circuit of activities/games during their session.  One or two of the activities/games focused on movement skills, with the remainder related to hockey.  Each group had a different colour of shirt making it easy to identify where they where as they moved around the 'circuit'.  
  • The coaching approach was generally facilitative, allowing the game to be the teacher.
  • The children come to coaching sessions once per week with a game each Saturday.  Saturday games range from 3v3 to 8v8 dependent on age, though games in training were as small as 2v2.

Youth Groups Aged 12-18:
  • Under 12's to Under 18's play 11v11.
  • Enjoyment and social elements are still central, alongside player development within this section of the club.
  • Teams train 2-3 times per week (reducing to 2 next season to reduce transport pressures for parents & encourage young people to participate in another sport/s) with a match on a Saturday.  There are multiple teams in each age group (E.g. the club has 11 Under 12 girls teams).
  • Within each age group the teams train as a team of 14-15 players.
  • One session per week will have a closed technical skill focus, this session has mixed groups.
  • The remainder of the sessions involve opposed dynamic hockey activities with lots of decision making.
  • Under 12 and 14 games play 4 or 5 mini seasons within one full season where they change the teams they play against.  The results of these games are not a focus for the club, the main focus is player's enjoyment and learning.
  • Under 16 and 18 games begin to turn attention to qualifying for higher level competitions for first two teams.  A championship exists for these age groups (it doesn't exist for U12 or U14).
  • A shared hockey language exists from this section of the club upwards in relation to game elements such as the section of the pitch that build up play begins (E.g. ball start (zone) 1), the section of the pitch that the ball is won in (E.g. ball win (zone) 3), and pressing.
  • A shared starting team formation exists, though coaches are permitted to move from this as the game requires, to act and react on pressure or opportunity from the opposition.
  • A shared development model and philosophy is in place within this section of the club which embraces technical, tactical, physical and mental player development; a player centred approach; and, personal/social development relating to discipline, competitiveness, perseverance and personal motivation.
  • The programme for each group is split in five blocks (including one indoor block) with each block having a defined focus relevant to that section of the season.  Each groups coaching team then develop the specifics of their programme within the focus of the block.
  • The top teams in each age group have their matches filmed and tagged for analysis, review and reflection.
  • Individualised feedback meetings with players take place 4 times per season (parents are invited to observe 2 of these per season).  An online player/coach reflection tool is used to inform and guide discussions, this allows both players and coaches to rate the physical, technical, tactical and mental aspects of their play out of five and then discuss.  A similar process supports the development of Youth Coaches at the club, using the same tool.
  • Separately a player assessment App (www.sportmonitor.net), again working on a scale of one to five creates a method of rating players in relation to aspects of their game.  This informs the placement of players into the clubs various teams.
  • The club operates a selection/assessment centre approach for players joining their secondary school age groups from other clubs.  This involves an open trial, filtered to a second trial with a smaller group, the group is filtered again with the remaining players training alongside the top team in the relevant age group prior to the club offering places to a maximum of 5 players.

Youth Match Observations
As part of our visit we were fortunate enough to watch matches involving HC Rotterdam's Under 12 Boys and Under 18 Girls teams.  Within both games, for me what stood out in comparison to similar levels of the game in Ulster was the tactical understanding of the players - perhaps a reflection, in part, of the ability to train consistently as a team in dynamic situations.  Watching high level club hockey on a regular basis is also likely to help players to develop their game-understanding.

Within the Under 12 Boys game notable observations were the players maintenance of their way of playing despite high pressing and consistent pressure from the opposition; and the measured coaching input during the game.  Pressed as far back as their own baseline the 'Back 3' players continued to play their way around the press either through composed passing play or through individual elimination.  While the coaching response elsewhere might have been to solve the problems for the young players and get the kids to play the ball long away from 'danger', the coaching was calm, infrequent during play and relaxed about the players taking risks.  This can only have a positive impact on players composure under pressure in the longer term.

From the Under 18 Girls game - the power, pace and elimination skills of one individual player was the stand out memory.  It was interesting to observe this within a fairly structured team set-up, with space for the individual to make a huge impact on the game.  Outside of that there was a high degree of consistency on how the team built up their play into attack, including high forward starting positions creating space to move back to into to collect the ball, the creation/execution of 2v1's from halfway to 23m lines; and counter control of the opposition.  


'Take Aways'
Having now returned home, a few of my 'take away' thoughts for my own coaching and the coaching at our club are:

  • Re-visiting the mini-hockey programme to see how we might create more pitch space for each group, in an ideal world achieving half a pitch per age group.
  • Working to get in place sufficient coach numbers to create smaller groups within Mini-Hockey and early stages of Youth Hockey, ideally around 8 players per group, and lower coach:player ratios (1:8). 
  • Fit the game to the players, not the other way around.  If players would benefit from 2v2 games, then create 2v2 games.  If a player would benefit from playing up a year, let them play up a year.  But consider the child's development stage and needs fully (physical, mental, technical, tactical & social) to inform these decisions.
  • Consider the value of creating 'teams' within our Under 14 and 15 age groups that allow the groups to train as a team, helping player to become used to working within a shared team structure prior to transition to Senior Hockey.  This could include some tactical direction from the Senior Coaches.  It also may be of benefit to merge the Under 14 and 15 groups into one group that has 3 or 4 teams.  The match day coaching approach could then align more effectively with things that the coaches are working on in training 'playing how you practice'. 
  • The smaller groups or team-based groups advocated above could then increase the capacity of coaches to provide quality feedback and facilitate player reflection.  These were strong qualities of Youth Hockey at HC Rotterdam.
  • Consider how Video Analysis can be introduced within the Under 14/15 teams as a learning and reflection tool.  It could potentially be used with younger Youth Hockey groups as well in a more informal way, including potentially encouraging self and peer coaching using video reflection through simple tools such as the 'Hudl-Technique' App which has a price accessible enough for young players to download to their smart phones.  This would require consideration of consent implications.
  • The general facilitative and empowering coaching approach observed, both in training and in games, was a further endorsement of what we are advocating within Youth and Mini Hockey at our club.  We probably aren't there yet, but observation of the work at HC Rotterdam supported the current direction of travel.
  • Hockey within Ulster, generally has as much or more time on pitch for players.  The difference is that the player contact time is probably more joined-up at HC Rotterdam as it's mostly within the club, where in Ulster the players time is split between School, Club and Regional/Provincial programmes.  It wouldn't be easy, but increasingly creating alignment between the delivery in the various hockey environments may enhance the impact on player development.
  • HC Rotterdam have embraced technology to help with player assessment, player reflection & learning and management of their programmes.  Elements such as the online player assessment tools probably aren't required a club level within Ulster as we don't have to manage the number of players that HC Rotterdam do, but it could be a useful tool at a provincial level.  Player reflection, video learning and general management efficiency could be supported though by embracing technological solutions at club level.
  • As a 'believer' in the Constraint's Led Approach to coaching, centred on the importance of maintaining the coupling of perception (assessing the problem facing the player and making a decision) and action (the movement selected to solve the problem), the isolated technique session once per week for Under 12 to Under 18 groups doesn't sit that comfortably with me.  However the bulk of coaching at HC Rotterdam is game-based and opposed and I will continue to encourage this approach within our club.
  • Make space and time for informal play and 'jumpers for goal-posts' games for the children around the club.
  • Consider how scheduling of training can help players maintain involvement in other sports.
  • Create more opportunities for young players to get involved in indoor hockey in the Winter months.
As is probably evident for the length of this post, there was a lot to take in during the visit and even more to consider afterwards.  I'm looking forward to putting lots of the learning into practice over the coming months!


Thanks
Thank you to Lisnagarvey Hockey Club for nominating me to be part of the clubs two-person delegation for the visit, and Invest in Sport Ltd with whom the club worked to secure funding to support this.

Thank you to the Erasmus+ programme who funded the visit.

Thanks to the staff at Ulster Hockey who allowed us to join our visit with a cohort of coaches and tutors that they were organising a visit for to the same location, and to those in the group who added to the learning from, and enjoyment of, the experience.  Also to Tour Rep. Julia who was a big help to the group throughout the visit.

Finally, thanks to everyone at HC Rotterdam who were very welcoming hosts - providing us with every possible opportunity to see and hear about what they do in all sections of the club.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Rotterdam or Anywhere (2): Everything Else

‘The Toothpaste Is Out Of The Tube’: Have The Past 2 Weeks Changed Local Sport Forever?